Every November, families across the country engage in friendly arguments over which dishes are non-negotiable on the Thanksgiving menu—and which ones can safely be skipped. Ahead of the 2026 holiday season, DoorDash decided to let hard numbers weigh in by analyzing what Americans actually ordered during Thanksgiving week the previous year.
While delivery data naturally captures store-bought items and last-minute restaurant orders rather than recipes baked from scratch in family kitchens, the results offer a fascinating snapshot of modern holiday cravings. From a classic autumn pie getting knocked off its pedestal to fierce state-by-state side-dish loyalties, the numbers prove that the "traditional" Thanksgiving spread looks wildly different depending on where you live.
Chocolate Cake Beats Pumpkin Pie
If you assumed pumpkin pie was the undisputed king of November desserts, DoorDash’s national rankings tell a very different story. When looking at store-bought pies and cakes ordered nationwide during Thanksgiving week, chocolate cake claimed the number one spot, leaving traditional autumn staples trailing behind. Here is how America’s top five Thanksgiving delivery desserts stacked up:
- Chocolate Cake
- Apple Pie
- Cheesecake
- Pumpkin Pie
- Pound Cake

Sweet Regional Divides Across the Map
Beyond the national top five, DoorDash examined which desserts individual states ordered at disproportionately higher rates compared to the national average, uncovering distinct regional sweet tooths. Despite landing in fourth place overall, pumpkin pie still dominated in 14 states, including California, Washington, and Arizona. Hawaii showed the fiercest devotion of all, ordering pumpkin pie at nearly three times the national share.
New York, Connecticut, and Massachusetts stayed loyal to classic apple pie, while neighboring New Jersey and Pennsylvania ordered pound cake at notably high rates. Farther north, Maine and New Hampshire stood out for their love of chocolate pie. Cheesecake surged ahead of the national average in eight states, led by strong showings in Illinois, Michigan, and Ohio. Pecan pie reigned supreme across Texas, Louisiana, and Tennessee. Meanwhile, Georgia threw a delicious curveball by favoring key lime pie over traditional fall flavors.
The Side-Dish Hierarchy and State Loyalties
When it came to savory accompaniments, comfort food classics dominated the national leaderboard. Mashed potatoes took the crown as America’s most-ordered Thanksgiving side, followed by corn, sweet potatoes, green beans, and gravy. Rounding out the national top ten were mac and cheese, stuffing, cornbread, carrots, and cranberries.
Zooming in on regional ordering habits, however, revealed sharp geographic preferences.

Cornbread outperformed the national average in Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi, while North Carolina and South Carolina leaned heavily into mac and cheese. Tennessee stood out for biscuits, and diners in Georgia, Alabama, and Florida ordered corn at higher-than-average rates. New York and New Jersey famously clash over pizza and bagels, yet DoorDash data shows the neighboring states found surprising common ground on Thanksgiving carrots. New Hampshire showed a strong preference for squash, while Vermont earned a unique distinction—it was the only state in the country where stuffing stood out as the top relative order.