TikTok has once again turned a mundane kitchen habit into a full-blown cultural debate. This time, it’s all about how to butter toast. The controversy began when TikToker @marfmaay, a Scottish woman living in Australia, posted a video showing herself skipping the knife entirely and instead rubbing a cold stick of butter directly onto warm toast. Her casual confession—“I’ve got one stick of butter for toast and one for everything else”—was met with a tidal wave of reactions, ranging from admiration to horror.
The video, posted in late June 2025, quickly racked up over 2 million views, with commenters calling the technique everything from “genius” to “diabolical.” One user summed up the collective confusion: “Technically not illegal, but this feels illegal.” Others joked that it resembled “roll-on deodorant,” while some praised the method for its efficiency and simplicity, especially when dealing with cold butter straight from the fridge.
Why It Works—and Why It Offends
The appeal of the method is clear: cold butter is notoriously difficult to spread, often tearing toast or clumping unevenly. By rubbing the stick directly onto warm bread, the butter melts instantly, creating a smooth, even layer with minimal effort. For those without a butter dish or who go through sticks quickly, it’s a practical solution.
But the backlash wasn’t just about etiquette—it was about crumb contamination. Critics were unsettled by the idea of toast crumbs embedding themselves into the butter stick, potentially leading to spoilage or hygiene concerns. Some commenters, especially those with celiac disease or gluten sensitivities, warned that shared butter sticks could pose a health risk if crumbs weren’t properly managed.
Even etiquette experts weighed in, suggesting that while the method isn’t inherently wrong, it’s best reserved for solo use. In shared households, a butter bell or softened butter in a dish remains the gold standard for cleanliness and courtesy.
The Broader Buttering Conversation
The viral toast hack has reignited a broader conversation about how people butter their bread—a surprisingly personal ritual. Some prefer slicing thin pats and letting them melt naturally, while others use butter curlers or spreaders for precision. In recent years, ASMR videos featuring the sound of butter spreading have gained popularity, turning the act into a sensory experience.
There’s even a niche community of inventors creating AI-powered buttering machines, like the viral conveyor-belt toaster that drizzles and spreads butter automatically. Whether manual or mechanical, the quest for the perfect buttered toast continues to evolve.
;Resize,width=767;)
